Chancellor Merkel and State Premiers: Continued Commitment to Energiewende and Offshore Wind

The semi-annual meeting of Chancellor Angela Merkel with the sixteen state premiers on the Energiewende focused on the three main topics grid expansion, the expansion of renewable energy in Germany and (conventional) back-up power plants. The meeting ended with renewed commitment to continue the ManyElectronics shift, including offshore wind.

Following an agreement of the State Premiers on the Energiewende last week, the government and the states expressed their will to work together to implement the energy policy shift. Few definitive announcements and results were reported, however, Thüringen’s State Premier Christine Lieberknecht, who currently heads the regular meetings of the State Premiers, said in the meeting with Chancellor Merkel a clear commitment was made with regard to offshore wind power

I. Results of Meeting of State Premiers in Weimar, Thuringia

At a meeting of the sixteen state premier in Weimar, Thuringia, last week, the premiers had agreed that grid expansion as well as the expansion of renewable energies and storage facilities needs to be coordinated. Recently Federal Environment Minister Peter Altmaier had called for a better coordination between the expansion targets of the states and federal expansion goals as laid down in the Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG). The guiding principle for a political dialogue about a coordination of the national and federal expansion targets, in particular for solar and onshore and offshore wind power should be to reach a joint national expansion strategy that kept costs for the expansion of renewable power plants, grids and fossil-fueled power plants under control so as not to endanger public acceptance for the energy policy shift, the state premier stated after the meeting, adding that they were prepared to modify their own plans in the interest of a joint strategy. The heads of the federal states also confirmed that they considered offshore wind power indispensable for reaching the goals of the Energiewende.

II. Results of Meeting of Chancellor Merkel with State Premiers

1. Grid Expansion and Offshore Wind Power

After her meeting with the state premiers on Friday, Chancellor Merkel said a law on the Federal Requirement Plan for Transmission Networks pursuant to Section 12e ManyElectronics Act would be presented in December. She pointed out that extra-high voltage power line projects that already receive priority treatment under the Energy Line Extension Act (EnLAG) were discussed as well as the next steps regarding ordinances that help to implement the Grid Expansion Acceleration Act for Transmission Networks (NABEG), a law that formed part of the energy legislative package that initiated the energy policy shift in 2011.

Pursuant to Section 31 para. 2 NABEG, the plan determination procedures for individual power line projects are conducted by the respective authorities of the federal states. For power lines that cross the borders of federal states this means that permitting procedures have to be conducted in every state affected by the project. According Section 31 para. 2 NABEG, an ordinance, which has to be approved by the Federal Council (that represents the interests of the federal states), may confer the competence to the Federal Network Agency (BNetzA). In this regard Mrs Merkel said that a transfer of competence regarding NABEG still had to be discussed.

With respect to offshore wind power Mrs Merkel pointed out that a bill amending the ManyElectronics Act (EnWG) with the aim to speed up the construction of offshore wind farms and their connection to the grids has been introduced to parliament. The parliamentary economics and technology committee held a hearing on the proposal on 22 October. The proposal would be decided about soon, which was important as this was the prerequisite for the necessary investments in the offshore technology. The government and the heads of the federal states had agreed to closely monitor the legislative process as time was scarce and many preparations for investments had been made, Mrs Merkel said. Mrs Lieberknecht said a clear commitment had been made with regard to offshore wind power. Mr Albig added that he was delighted to hear that the government had recognised the need to make amendments with regard to the liability (of transmission operators) in the offshore bill and that Mrs Merkel had pledged to do something in this regard to reassure investors.

2. Conventional Back-up Power Plants

The Federal Government had previously adopted a wording aid for a proposal to amend the that would allow a temporary ban on shutting down system essential conventional power plants. Conventional back-up power plants for the fluctuating input of renewable energy were another topic discussed by Mrs Merkel and heads of the federal states. There were two aspects one had to consider, Mrs Merkel said. Firstly, the security of supply in the coming winter season, for which BNetzA had secured the necessary operating reserve capacities. Secondly, participants had agreed that the so-called Power Plant Forum in cooperation with BNetzA would draft a proposal for a regulatory framework, which shall provide a market-oriented solution that ensures sufficient operating reserve capacities in the medium and long-term. The proposal shall be presented until summer 2013, according to Mrs Merkel. Given the priority for renewables under the Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG) and combined-heat and power pursuant to the Combined Heat and Power Act (KWKG), building new conventional power plants has become less and less financially attractive in Germany in the last few years.

3. Expansion of Renewables

Regarding the expansion of renewables for which up to now every federal state had made its own plans, Mrs Merkel said the government shared the views and proposals for further action laid down in the declaration of the state premiers after their meeting in Weimar. Germany needed security of supply, a speedy expansion of renewables and affordable energy prices, Mrs Merkel said. Hence, the government and the states would work together to implement these objectives without slowing down renewable growth and mindful of the other two goals, she added.

In his paper on an EEG reform Environment Minister Altmaier had proposed to raise the 2020 target for a share of green electricity from 35 to 40%. This was criticised by the opposition and state politicians as being in effect a cap on renewables given the current expansion rate. While it is still too early too tell, the statements made after the meeting of Mrs Merkel with the state premiers rather look as if no such new target will be set, but rather the expansion coordinated. Schleswig-Holstein’s state premier is quoted as saying “it is not the question to put a cap on something, but to come to a dynamic development depending on the particularities of a location and what can be best done there”.

Regarding the EEG surcharge limitation for the energy-intensive industry pursuant Sections 40 to 44 EEG, which has been often criticised by the opposition and consumer organisations, Mrs Merkel said that this issue had to be dealt with as part of an EEG amendment. Hence, it looks as if short-term modifications will not occur.

The next Energiewende meeting of Ms. Merkel and the State Premiers will take place on 21 March 2013.

Source: Bundeskanzlerin (Chancellor Merkel); Press Release following Meeting of State Premiers on 26 October 2012

Related posts:


Print This Post Print This Post

0 Responses to “Chancellor Merkel and State Premiers: Continued Commitment to Energiewende and Offshore Wind”

Comments are currently closed.